Peace Pie (Cape May) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Featured Items
Blueberry Cobbler
$8.59
Molten Chocolate
$8.59
Triple Vanilla
$8.59
Cookies ’N Cream
$8.59
Pecan Pie
$8.59
Key Lime Pie
$8.59
Peaches N' Cream
$8.59
PB Cookie Dough
$8.59
Strawberry Shortcake
$8.59
PB Pretzel
$8.59
Blueberry Lemon Drop
$8.59
Cinnamon Bun
$8.59
Cherry Pie
$8.59
Cookie Dough
$8.59
PB Blondie
$8.59
Coconut Cream
$8.59
#3 Most liked
Coffee Toffee
$8.59
Bananas Foster
$8.59
#2 Most liked
Peanut Butter Cup
$8.59
Jersey Devil
$8.59
Creme Brulee
$8.59
Rocky Road
$8.59
The Elvis
$8.59
Caramel Apple
$8.59
Triple Chocolate Brownie
$8.59
Full Menu
12:00 pm - 10:40 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Caramel Brownie
#1 Most liked
Our Best Seller from the very start The Salted Caramel Brownie is Vanilla Ice Cream topped with our House-made caramel and fudge brownie bites sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies!
$8.59•100% (15)
Peanut Butter Cup
#2 Most liked
Peace Pie's Peanut Butter Cup is the perfect combination of Chocolate Ice Cream and our Deliciously Creamy Peanut Butter Mousse on two crispy Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (12)
Coffee Toffee
#3 Most liked
Our Classic Coffee Ice Cream Sandwich, topped with our House-made Caramel and Toffee Crumble on Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (11)
Cookie Dough
One of our most popular! Experience Cookie Dough and Ice Cream like you've never had it before. Two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies, layered with Creamy Chocolate Mousse with house-made cookie dough bites swirled on top of Vanilla Ice Cream.
$8.59•90% (11)
Chocolate Mint
Chocolate shortbread cookie with chocolate mousse and mint chip ice cream.
$8.59•100% (6)
Strawberry Shortcake
A refreshing scoop of Strawberry Ice Cream topped with a layer of creamy Vanilla Mousse, sandwiched between two Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (7)
Triple Chocolate Brownie
For the True Chocolate Lover: Chocolate Ice Cream, Chocolate Mousse, House-made Brownies, sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (9)
Creme Brulee
Vanilla ice cream topped with a layer of vanilla custard and house made caramel with toffee crumble between two butter shortbread cookies
$8.59•100% (9)
PB Pretzel
Peanut Butter Ice cream with our signature house-made Caramel over a pretzel and sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (7)
Bananas Foster
Our House-made Caramel with Vanilla Mousse and Banana Ice Cream sandwiched between two Cinnamon Cookies
$8.59•100% (6)
ONLINE & INSTORE
Banana Cream
Our House-made Custard with Banana Butter over a scoop of vanilla ice cream sandwiched with two graham cracker cookies
$8.59•100% (6)
Banana Split
Banana Ice Cream with Cherry Pie Filling and Chocolate Mousse on two Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
Bananas Foster
Our House-made Caramel with Vanilla Mousse and Banana Ice Cream sandwiched between two Cinnamon Cookies
$8.59•100% (6)
Blueberry Cobbler
Blueberry Ice Cream with a layer of our house-made Vanilla Mousse on two Graham Cracker Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
Blueberry Lemon Drop
Butter shortbread cookie with lemon mousse and lemon candy on blueberry ice cream
$8.59
Boston Cream Pie
Shortbread Cookie, Custard, Chocolate Mousse, Vanilla Ice Cream
$8.59
Candy Bar
Our House-made Custard with Banana Butter over a scoop of vanilla ice cream sandwiched with two graham cracker cookies
$8.59•100% (7)
Caramel Apple
Cinnamon Cookie, Apple Pie Filling, Caramel, Vanilla Ice Cream
$8.59
Caramel Brownie
#1 Most liked
Our Best Seller from the very start The Salted Caramel Brownie is Vanilla Ice Cream topped with our House-made caramel and fudge brownie bites sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies!
$8.59•100% (15)
Cherry Pie
Vanilla Ice cream topped with a layer of Cherry Pie and Vanilla Mousse on two Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Chocolate Cookie, Chocolate Chips, Chocolate Mousse, Strawberry Ice Cream
$8.59
Chocolate Mint
Chocolate shortbread cookie with chocolate mousse and mint chip ice cream.
$8.59•100% (6)
Chocolate Raspberry
Chocolate shortbread cookie with chocolate mousse on raspberry ice cream
$8.59
Cinnamon Bun
Cinnamon Swirl Ice Cream topped with a layer of our house-made Caramel and Vanilla Mousse sandwiched between two Cinnamon Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (7)
Coconut Cream
Shortbread Cookie, Coconut Custard, Vanilla Ice Cream
$8.59•100% (7)
Coffee Toffee
#3 Most liked
Our Classic Coffee Ice Cream Sandwich, topped with our House-made Caramel and Toffee Crumble on Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (11)
Cookie Dough
One of our most popular! Experience Cookie Dough and Ice Cream like you've never had it before. Two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies, layered with Creamy Chocolate Mousse with house-made cookie dough bites swirled on top of Vanilla Ice Cream.
$8.59•90% (11)
Cookies ’N Cream
Our take on the Classic Ice Cream Sandwich, Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate & Vanilla Mousse on Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
Creamsicle
Refreshing Orange Sherbet topped with our creamy Vanilla Mousse on Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
Creme Brulee
Vanilla ice cream topped with a layer of vanilla custard and house made caramel with toffee crumble between two butter shortbread cookies
$8.59•100% (9)
Jersey Devil
The one and only JERSEY DEVIL Peace Pie is all Red White & Blue with Blueberry Ice Cream topped with a layer of Cherry Pie Filling and Vanilla Mousse sandwiched between two Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
Key Lime Pie
Our Delicious Key Lime Pie Mousse with a Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream Served Between Our Crunchy Cinnamon Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
Molten Chocolate
Our Signature all chocolate pie, Chocolate Ice Cream with a layer of Chocolate Mousse sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
Party Pie
Chocolate Ice Cream topped with a layer of Vanilla Mousse and Rainbow Sprinkles sandwiched between two Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
PB Blondie
Butter shortbread cookie with peanut butter mousse and brownies on vanilla ice cream.
$8.59
PB Brownie
Chocolate shortbread cookie with peanut butter chiffon, caramel, and brownies on peanut butter ice cream.
$8.59
PB Cookie Dough
Chocolate shortbread cookie with peanut butter chiffon and cookie dough on chocolate ice cream.
$8.59
PB Pretzel
Peanut Butter Ice cream with our signature house-made Caramel over a pretzel and sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (7)
Peaches N' Cream
Peach Ice Cream topped with our signature Vanilla Mousse, sandwiched between two Graham Cracker Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
Peanut Butter Cup
#2 Most liked
Peace Pie's Peanut Butter Cup is the perfect combination of Chocolate Ice Cream and our Deliciously Creamy Peanut Butter Mousse on two crispy Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (12)
Pecan Pie
The original Peace Pie is our Pecan Pie; made with the family's homemade Pecan Pie filling recipe, over Vanilla Ice Cream sandwiched between two of our delicious Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (8)
Rocky Road
Rocky Road reinvented with our Delicious Chocolate Mousse, swirled with Almond Slivers and Mini Marshmallows over Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwiched Between Two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
$8.59
S'mores - Regular Price
Peace Pie's frozen take on the American Classic Chocolate Ice Cream with a layer of Chocolate Mousse and Mini Marshmallows sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies!
$8.59
Strawberry Shortcake
A refreshing scoop of Strawberry Ice Cream topped with a layer of creamy Vanilla Mousse, sandwiched between two Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (7)
The Elvis
Our delicious house-made banana butter with creamy peanut butter mousse over chocolate ice cream sandwiched between two crunchy chocolate shortbread cookies
$8.59
Thin Mint
Our house-made whipped mint mousse, over chocolate ice cream on two chocolate shortbread cookies
$8.59
Triple Chocolate Brownie
For the True Chocolate Lover: Chocolate Ice Cream, Chocolate Mousse, House-made Brownies, sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (9)
Triple Vanilla
Creamy Vanilla Mousse over a scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream on our Original Butter Shortbread Cookies
$8.59•100% (7)
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash