e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from Pizza Joe's at 1203 North Croton Avenue in New Castle. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

Pizza Joe's 1203 North Croton Avenue - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to Pizza Joe's to pick up this order: 1203 North Croton Avenue

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

12 Cut Square

Broccoli and cauliflower, covered in white sauce and Cheddar/Mozzarella cheese.

Vegetable

9 Cut Square

Fresh dough with oil and spices topped with Romano and Mozzarella cheeses.  Includes choice of one sauce.

Dip-n- Stix

6 Cut Round

Ham, salami, pepperoni, and Mozzarella topped with lettuce, tomato, and creamy Italian dressing.

Hot Gondola Sub

Order of Wings (Dozen)

8 Cut Round

Dough fold over, stuffed with pepperoni, sausage mushrooms, banana peppers, sweet peppers, olives, sauce, and Mozzarella cheese.

PJ's Original Stromboli

Just like veggie pizza, but dipped in your favorite sauce!  Choice of one sauce included.

Veggie Stix

Popular Items

Dip-N-Stix with delicious pepperoni! Choice of one sauce included. 

Pepperoni Stix

6-cut pizza shell topped with cinnamon topper and icing.

Cinna-Stix

Side of Sauce

Appetizers & Add-Ons

Lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, banana peppers, pepperoni, Cheddar/Mozzarella.

Tossed Salad

Our tossed salad with grilled chicken and French fries.

Chicken Salad

Our tossed salad with ham, pepperoni, and salami.

Antipasto Salad

Salads

All subs are toasted on a 9" Italian bun.

Gyro Joe is baked on a 10" pizza shell with lamb and mozzarella cheese. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and ranch dressing. 

Gyro Joe

Meatball Sub

Pepperoni, sauce, banana peppers, and Mozzarella cheese.

Superoni Sub

Grilled chicken and Mozzarella cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.

Chicken Sub

Toasted 9" Super Subs

We offer gluten free & low-carb cauliflower crust try cauliflower crust as a dip-n-stix.

Gluten Free (6 Cut)

Pizza Your Way

Seasoned spinach, topped with fresh tomatoes, banana peppers, and Romano and Mozzarella cheeses.

Spinach Italiano

Our traditional pizza topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and green peppers.

The Ultimate

Our traditional pizza with all your favorite meat - pepperoni, sausage, ham and bacon!

Meat Monster

Chicken and onions covered in bbq sauce with Cheddar/Mozzarella cheese.

BBQ Chicken

Chicken covered in spicy buffalo sauce topped with Cheddar/Mozzarella cheese.

Buffalo Chicken

Chicken and bacon with white sauce and Cheddar/Mozzarella cheese

Chicken Bacon Club

Chicken in a sweet and spicy Thai glaze with Romano and Cheddar/Mozzarella cheeses.

Sweet Honey Hot Chicken

Specialty Pizzas

Dough fold over, stuffed with meatballs, sauce and Mozzarella cheese.

Meatball Stromboli

Dough fold over, stuffed with 100% ricotta, Romano and Mozzarella cheese and our delicious sauce.

Original Cheese Calzone

Meatball Calzone

Strombolis & Calzones

Side of Ranch

Wings

Wedges are prepared on a 10" pizza shell & folded in half

Meatball

Pepperoni, sauce, banana peppers, and Mozzarella cheese

Superoni

Hot Gondola

Chicken

Slices of gyro meat and Mozzarella cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing.

Gyro Joe (Lamb)

Wedges

All Day

Full Menu

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

I wish the cinastick icing came on the side. other then that great.

croton ave new castle pa is the worst place to get regular stromboli with extraccheese and mushrooms no sugage pepperoni or sace just xcheese and mushroom how is that a regular stromboli better be specific with ur order

Pizza Joe's

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

Popular Items

Appetizers & Add-Ons

Salads

Toasted 9" Super Subs

Pizza Your Way

Specialty Pizzas

Strombolis & Calzones

Wings

Wedges

Pizza Joe's (#025 - Croton Ave) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery