e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from Simply Greekalicious at 1274 Wantagh Avenue in Wantagh. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

Simply Greekalicious 1274 Wantagh Avenue - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to Simply Greekalicious to pick up this order: 1274 Wantagh Avenue

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

romaine, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, peppers, dolma, kalamata olives and feta cheese served with our house evoo vinaigrette.

Greek Salad

Lamb and Beef Gyro Sandwich 

Chicken Souvlaki served with two sides of your choice: veggies, soup, salad, french fries, rice, Greek salad, or lemon potatoes.

Chicken Souvlaki Platter

Savor a platter of lamb and beef gyro, presented with your selection of two sides. Choose from lemon potatoes, soup, Greek salad, French fries, veggies, rice, or a combo of soup and salad.

Lamb and Beef Gyro Platter

Served w/lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce

Chicken Souvlaki Sandwich

traditional greek egg, lemon chicken soup.

Avgolemono Soup 16oz

Spanakopita

Chicken doner, lettuce, tomato, onion & tzatziki sce

Chicken Doner Gyro Sandwich

Savor the taste of meticulously grilled chicken, tender and succulent. Served in quantities of one, two, or three skewers, each piece is imbued with authentic Greek flavours, offering a truly scrumptious delight.

Chicken

Tzatziki dip with yogurt, cucumber and garlic, offered with toasted regular or whole wheat pita.

Tzatziki

Popular Items

Enjoy a hearty gyro sandwich with your choice of protein options: pork souvlaki, chicken doner, lamb/beef, or chicken souvlaki, served with a generous side of fries.

Gyro Sand & Fries SP

Savor the robust flavors of your selected protein, be it crispy falafel, succulent grilled chicken, charred veggies, or perfectly seasoned souvlaki, each one presenting a delightful taste of Greek culinary authenticity.

Greek Bowls  SP

Handcrafted on fluffy mini pita. Authentic flavors. Guacamole  , feta, chipotle chicken, pork al pastor,  shrimp, pico and our Pink sauce.

Greek Tacos SP

Chicken Tenders (3) &  Fries  SP

Crispy Chicken Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion & BBQ sauce

Crispy Chicken Pita SP

Moussaka w/rice & salad.  SP

Lamb/beef gyro over rice , LTO, olives ,feta all in one box
Pita & tzatziki

Lunch Box lamb/beef

Chicken gyro over rice , LTO, olives ,feta all in one box
Pita & tzatziki 

Lunch Box Chicken gyro

Pork Souvlaki over rice , LTO, olives, feta, pita & tzatziki 

Lunch Box Pork souvlaki

Lamb/beef gyro over rice , LTO, olives,  feta , pita & tzatziki 

Lunch Box Grilld Chicken 

 Specials

Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki. Make it Deluxe add Fresh Cut Fries for additional cost.

Pork Souvlaki Sandwich

Leg of lamb chunks lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki

Lamb Souvlaki Sandwich

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Loukaniko Sandwich 

Keftedakia Sandwich 

Skirt Steak Sandwich 

Grilled Shrimp Sandwich 

Falafel Sandwich 

Select from beef gyro, chicken doner, or lamb gyro in a hearty sandwich.

Lamb / Beef Gyro & Chicken Doner Sandwich 

Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich 

Crispy Chicken Pita 

Gyro panini. Choice of beef/ lamb gyro or chicken doner, lettuce, tomato, red onion, tzatziki, french fries and mozzarella all pressed between 2 pitas

Skepasti

Chicken Donner Buffalo Sauce topped with creamy Bleu cheese 

Buffalo Bleu

Philly steak with peppers & onions topped with melted American cheese

Philly Steak Pita 

Sandwiches

Classic Burger

With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

Burger Deluxe

Cheeseburger

choice of American or Mozzarella. With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

Cheeseburger Deluxe

Greek Burger

feta, tomato and onion. With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

Greek Burger Deluxe

Grilled Chicken Burger

Grilled Chicken Burger Deluxe

Philly Steak Burger

peppers, onion and cheese. With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

Philly Steak Burger Deluxe

Falafel Burger

hummus, lettuce, tomato and pickle. With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

Falafel Burger Deluxe

Charbroiled Angus Burgers

gyro, lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki

Gyro Lovers

chicken souvlaki, lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki

Grecian

chicken doner, lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki

Athenian

Philly Steak

Greek Salad Wrap

Grilled Veggie Wrap

Falafel Wrap

chicken, spicy feta, rice, avocado, tomato & onion

Greek Burrito

grilled chicken, romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion, peppers, olives, feta cheese and our house vinaigrette

Mediterranean

grilled shrimp, romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion, peppers, avocado & pink sauce

Grilled Shrimp Wrap

romaine, parmesan cheese, caesar dressing & grilled chicken

Chicken Caesar Wrap

grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato & pink sauce

Chicken Club

grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato & honey mustard

Honey Mustard Chicken

skirt steak, romaine, tomato, red onion & bleu cheese dressing

Steakhouse

Wraps

Baklava

Baklava Cheesecake

Fried Oreos (5)

Rice Pudding

Galaktoboureko (Custard Pie)

Revani (Semolina Cake)

Greek zeppoles loukoumades, a traditional dessert, coated with options of powdered sugar, Nutella and walnuts, honey and cinnamon, honey with walnuts and cinnamon, or just Nutella.

Greek Zeppoles (Loukoumades) 

Greek orange Fillo cake. Fluffy and colorful soaked in a delicious orange scented syrup.

Portokalopita 

Chocolate Temptation

Savor our thick and creamy yogurt, traditionally made. Delight in the tart, tantalizing notes of the sour cherry preserve or enjoy the sweet, comforting essence of honey paired with crunchy, earthy walnuts.

Greek Yogurt

Desserts

10 pork or chicken skewers, pita bread, tzatziki, fresh cut fries, greek salad and 1.25 liter soda

Souvlaki Feast Combo

choice of 4 gyro sandwiches (lamb, beef or chicken doner), fresh cut fries, greek salad and 1.25 liter soda

Gyro Lovers Combo

1/2 tray lamb/beef & chicken gyro, 1/2 tray rice or french fries, 1/2 tray greek salad, pita bread & tzatziki, (12) loukoumades with honey cinnamon

Family Style

Greekalikious Combos

Souvlaki & Fries Plate

Choose between succulent lamb/beef or tender chicken, served with a hearty portion of french fries. Perfect for those in need of a satisfyingly classic taste.

Gyro & Fries Plate

Chicken Tenders (3) & Fries

Hamburgers & Fries

Mozzarella Sticks  (4) & Fries

Cheese Quesadilla & Fries

Choice of  Protein, lettuce, tomato, red onion, feta and choice of fries or Rice 

Kids Box

Kids Menu

Coffee

Greek Frappe

Iced Coffee

Cans

Classic Glass Bottles

Snapple

Bottled Water

Greek Specialty Drink

Enjoy a refreshing 5 liter beverage, with an option to select from Lemon-Lime, Diet Cola, or Cola flavors.

1.25 Liter Sodas

Fresh Lemonade

Sour Cherry Lemonade

Beverages

Feta Cheese

Spinach Pie Triangles (4) or Cheese Pie triangles  (4)

ground chickpea balls with herbs & spices and hummus & tahini sauce

Falafel (6) Appetizer 

Dolmathakia (6)

Greek pork sausage with leeks served with lemon and tzatziki

Loukaniko

marinated pork or chicken skewers. Served with pita bread and tzatziki

Mini Souvlaki (4)

Greek seasoned fried meatballs served with lemon and tzatziki

Keftedakia

Fried Calamari (Kalamarakia)

served with tzatziki sauce or tirokafteri.

Pita Chips

fried seasoned pita strips served with tzatziki sauce

Pita Fries

regular, crispy or glazed in our buffalo sauce served with bleu cheese

Buffalo Wings (6)

Chicken Fingers (5)

Mozzarella Sticks (6)

Zucchini Sticks

Grilled Shrimp Appetizer 

lamb & beef gyro, chicken doner, loukaniko, marinated pork & chicken cubes, fresh cut fries, served with pita and tzatziki sauce

Greek Sampler

(6) mozzarella sticks, (6) buffalo wings. (6) chicken fingers served with fresh cut fries and dipping sauces

American Sampler

pita chips with lamb/beef or chicken topped with lettuce, & tomato, onion, feta, olives, pepperoncini & tzatziki

Greek Nachos

Handcrafted on fluffy mini pita. Authentic flavors. Guacamole  , feta, chipotle chicken, pico and our Pink sauce.

Greek  Tacos  (chicken)

Handcrafted on fluffy mini pita. Authentic flavors. Guacamole  , feta, chipotle pork al pastor , pico and our Pink sauce.

Greek Tacos (pork)

Handcrafted on fluffy mini pita. Authentic flavors. Guacamole  , feta, chipotle shrimp , pico and our Pink sauce.

Greek Tacos (shrimp)

Appetizers

All dips served with toasted regular or whole wheat pita

Tyrokafteri

Chickpeas and tahini blend, seasoned with garlic, topped with olive oil. Options: Whole Wheat Pita or Toasted Regular.

Hummus

Tzatziki, hummus, spicy feta & pita bread

Dip Combo

Melitzanosalata (Eggplant)

Dips

Traditional greek salad. Tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, kalamata olives, peppers and feta cheese tossed with evool and oregano

Horiatiki Salad

Mesclun, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, Kalamata olives and peppers served with our house extra virgin olive oil vinaigrette dressing.

Simply Greekalicious

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

Popular Items

Specials

Sandwiches

Charbroiled Angus Burgers

Wraps

Desserts

Greekalikious Combos

Kids Menu

Beverages

Appetizers

Dips

Salads

Skewers

Soup

Platters

Extras

Sides

Simply Greekalicious Near Me - Pickup and Delivery