Stuff-A-Bagel (Montauk Hwy) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Stuff-A-Bagel
425 Montauk Highway, West Islip, NY
Online ordering hours: 5:00 AM - 1:45 PMOpens 5:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
#1 Most liked
Bacon and Egg Sandwich
$11.95
#2 Most liked
1/2 Dozen Bagels
$15.95
#3 Most liked
Plain Cream Cheese
$7.95
1 Dozen Bagels
$26.95
Sausage and Egg Sandwich
$12.50
Ham and Egg Sandwich
$11.95
Jumbo Egg Sandwich
$8.95
Ham and Cheese Omelette
$13.50
Mixed Cream Cheese
$8.95
Buttered Bagel
$5.75
Nova Lox and Cream Cheese
$19.95
1 lb. Mixed Cream Cheese
$18.95
1/2 lb. Mixed Cream Cheese
$10.95
Potato and Egg Sandwich
$12.95
Nesquik Milk 14 oz.
$4.50
1/4 lb. Mixed Cream Cheese
$5.95
16 oz. Tropicana Orange Juice
$4.50
Buttered Roll
$5.75
Breakfast
5:00 am - 1:45 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Bacon and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, Bacon on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate.
$11.95•45
#1 Most liked
1/2 Dozen Bagels
Describe in order notes the number of selected bagels.
$15.95•29
#2 Most liked
Plain Cream Cheese
$7.95•27
#3 Most liked
Buttered Bagel
$5.75•10
Sausage and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, Sausage Patty on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate.
$12.50•9
Nesquik Milk 14 oz.
Chocolate, Strawberry
$4.50•11
1 Dozen Bagels
Describe in order notes the number of selected bagels.
$26.95•14
16 oz. Tropicana Orange Juice
16 oz.
$4.50•8
Coffee
$3.95•12
Homemade Sweet Ice Tea
$6.99•9
Breakfast Sandwiches
Bacon and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, Bacon on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate.
$11.95•45
#1 Most liked
Ham and Cheese Omelette
Scrambled eggs, with ham and cheese Omelette on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate
$13.50
Cheese Omelette
Scrambled Eggs and Cheese Omelet on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate
$9.95
Egg Whites and Turkey Sandwich
Two Egg Whites, Turkey on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate
$14.95•9
Ham and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, and Ham on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate
$11.95•8
Hungry Man on a roll or bagel
Three eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, and cheese on a bagel or roll.
$16.95
Jumbo Egg Sandwich
Two eggs on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate
$8.95•8
Potato and Egg Sandwich
Homefried Potatoes and Two Eggs on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate.
$12.95
Sausage and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, Sausage Patty on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate.
$12.50•9
Western Omelette
Scrambled eggs with ham, green, and red peppers, onions and cheese
$14.95
On a Bagel
Buttered Bagel
$5.75•10
Mixed Cream Cheese
Olive, strawberry, bacon and cheddar, vegetable, scallion cinnamon raisin, walnut, chocolate chip, vegetable, and scallion.
$8.95•11
Plain Cream Cheese
$7.95•27
#3 Most liked
Buttered Roll
$5.75
Cream Cheese and Jelly
$7.95
Lox Cream Cheese
$14.95
Nova Lox and Cream Cheese
$19.95
Cream Cheese
1 lb. Mixed Cream Cheese
Olive strawberry bacon and cheddar vegetable scallion cinnamon raisin walnut chocolate chip vegetable and scallion.
$18.95
1/2 lb. Mixed Cream Cheese
$10.95
1/4 lb. Mixed Cream Cheese
$5.95•6
1/2 lb. Plain Cream Cheese
$9.95•6
1/4 lb. Plain Cream Cheese
$5.95
1 lb. Plain Cream Cheese
$17.95
Butter
1/2 lb. Butter
$9.95
1/4 lb. Butter
$5.95
1 lb. Butter
$18.95
1 Dozen Bagels
1 Dozen Bagels
Describe in order notes the number of selected bagels.
$26.95•14
1/2 Dozen Bagels
1/2 Dozen Bagels
Describe in order notes the number of selected bagels.
$15.95•29
#2 Most liked
Beverages
Coffee
$3.95•12
Nesquik Milk 14 oz.
Chocolate, Strawberry
$4.50•11
Tea
$3.95
16 oz. Tropicana Orange Juice
16 oz.
$4.50•8
20oz Bottle Soda
Coke, Diet Coke, Ginger
$4.95
Homemade Sweet Ice Tea
$6.99•9
Ice Coffee
$6.99•5
Snapple
Ice tea, Diet Ice tea, Half & Half, Peach, Diet Peach
$4.50
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash