The Juicy Seafood (Castleton) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
The Juicy Seafood
5899 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, USA12 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
#1 Most liked
Make Your Own Seafood Combo
$10.40+
#2 Most liked
Mr. Captain
$48.09
#3 Most liked
Snow Crab Legs (2 Clusters )
$42.89
Red Bomb
$55.89
Shrimp (No Head) (1 lb)
$35.09
Crawfish (1 lb)
$22.09
King Crab Legs (1 lb)
$116.00
Chicken Wings
$10.40
Fire Bird for Two
$116.99
Fried Catfish Basket (4)
$19.50
Corn On The Cob (3)
$4.23
Sausage
$10.40
Shrimp (Head On) (1 lb)
$25.99
Two Items Combo
$19.50
Potato (3)
$4.23
Hush Puppies (10)
$4.55
Green Mussel (1 lb)
$22.09
Black & Red for Two
$109.19
Black Mussel (1 lb)
$20.79
Chicken Tender Basket (4)
$19.50
Fried Shrimp Basket (8)
$18.20
The Black Pearl
$200.19
Dungeness (2 Clusters )
$44.19
Cajun Fries
$5.85
Side Broccoli
$4.88
Full Menu
12:00 pm - 9:40 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Make Your Own Seafood Combo
#1 Most liked
Choose TWO or more Seafood items to make a combo that comes with 1 corn and 2 potatoes. Please note, choosing only One item will not come with sides unless added.
$10.40+•80% (375)
Mr. Captain
#2 Most liked
1 Clusters of snow crab legs, half pound shrimp (no head), half pound sausage and two eggs with one corn and two potatoes.
$48.09•82% (182)
Snow Crab Legs (2 Clusters )
#3 Most liked
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$42.89•88% (134)
Red Bomb
One lobster tail, 1 Clusters of snow crab legs and half pound shrimp (no head) with one corn and two potatoes.
$55.89•83% (97)
Shrimp (No Head) (1 lb)
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$35.09•93% (80)
Chicken Wings
Chicken on the bone.
$10.40•80% (56)
Corn On The Cob (3)
Vegan.
$4.23•94% (55)
Hush Puppies (10)
Golden-brown cornmeal fritters with a crispy exterior and tender inside, served with a tangy dipping sauce.
$4.55•86% (65)
Potato (3)
Vegan.
$4.23•93% (45)
Fried Catfish Basket (4)
Crispy catfish served with choice of fries, onion rings, or steamed white rice. Accompanied by tartar, ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard, cocktail, or marinara sauce.
$19.50•92% (57)
Starters
Chicken Wings
Chicken on the bone.
$10.40•80% (56)
Crab Cakes (2) (Imitation Crab)
Two crispy crab cakes made with imitation crab, served with a lemon wedge and dipping sauce.
$10.40•66% (9)
Fried Calamari (15)
Crispy, golden-brown calamari rings served with a tangy marinara sauce.
$11.05•78% (14)
Hush Puppies (10)
Golden-brown cornmeal fritters with a crispy exterior and tender inside, served with a tangy dipping sauce.
$4.55•86% (65)
Mozzarella Cheese Stick (6)
Golden-brown mozzarella sticks, crispy on the outside, with gooey melted cheese inside. Served with a side of tangy marinara sauce.
$7.15•91% (12)
New England Clam Chowder
A thick creamy soup.
$11.70
Onion Rings (12)
Crispy, golden-brown onion rings, perfectly battered and fried, served with a side of creamy dipping sauce.
$8.45
Seafood Gumbo Soup
A hearty blend of shrimp, crab, and okra in a rich, savory broth, seasoned with Creole spices.
$14.30•75% (16)
*Steamed Oyster
*This menu items may be served raw or undercooked. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
$16.90•81% (16)
Get Your Hand Dirty
Shrimp (Head On) (1 lb)
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$25.99•82% (17)
Snow Crab Legs (2 Clusters )
#3 Most liked
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$42.89•88% (134)
Crawfish (1 lb)
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$22.09•86% (30)
Shrimp (No Head) (1 lb)
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$35.09•93% (80)
Green Mussel (1 lb)
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$22.09•71% (21)
Black Mussel (1 lb)
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$20.79•91% (12)
King Crab Legs (1 lb)
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$116.00•82% (17)
Sea Scallops (1 lb)
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$50.69•100% (6)
Lobster Tail (2)
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$49.39•80% (10)
Clams (1 lb)
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$20.79
Dungeness (2 Clusters )
Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
$44.19
Make Your Own Seafood Combo
Choose any two or more seafood items. Comes with one corn and two potatoes. Add two boiled eggs or 1/2 lb sausage for an additional cost.
Make Your Own Seafood Combo
#1 Most liked
Choose TWO or more Seafood items to make a combo that comes with 1 corn and 2 potatoes. Please note, choosing only One item will not come with sides unless added.
$10.40+•80% (375)
Something Fried
Basket comes with your choice of sauce and cajun fries, substitute onion rings for an additional cost.
Fried Shrimp Basket (8)
Eight crispy fried shrimp in a basket. Choose from regular, Cajun, or sweet potato fries, onion rings, or steamed white rice. Sauce options include tartar, ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard, cocktail, and marinara.
$18.20•85% (14)
Chicken Tender Basket (4)
Chicken tenders accompanied by a choice of fries, onion rings, or steamed white rice. Select from tartar, ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard, cocktail, or marinara sauce.
$19.50•81% (16)
Fried Oyster Basket (10)
Crispy fried oysters, ten count. Choose sides: fries (regular or Cajun), onion rings, sweet potato fries, or steamed white rice. Sauce options: tartar, ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard, cocktail, marinara.
$19.50
Fried Catfish Basket (4)
Crispy catfish served with choice of fries, onion rings, or steamed white rice. Accompanied by tartar, ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard, cocktail, or marinara sauce.
$19.50•92% (57)
Whiting Fillet Basket (2)
Two crispy whiting fillets served with a choice of sides: fries (regular or Cajun), onion rings, sweet potato fries, or steamed white rice. Selection of sauces includes tartar, ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard, cocktail, or marinara.
$16.90•72% (18)
Fried Shrimp (1 lb)
1 lb of crispy fried shrimp, served with a choice of tartar, ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard, cocktail, or marinara sauce.
$28.60•93% (16)
Fried Tilapia Basket (4)
Fried tilapia served in a basket, choice of side: fries (regular or Cajun), onion rings, sweet potato fries, or steamed white rice. Sauce options include tartar, ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard, cocktail, or marinara.
$16.90•85% (7)
Two Items Combo
Choose any two items, comes with Regular fires or Cajun fries.
$19.50•88% (27)
Special Combo
Black & Red for Two
Two lobster tails, 1 Clusters of snow crab legs, half pound shrimp (no head) and half pound black mussels with two corn and two potatoes.
$109.19•100% (8)
Fire Bird for Two
Half pound king crab, 1 Clusters of snow crab, half pound shrimp (no head) and half pound sausage with two corn, two potatoes and two eggs.
$116.99•85% (21)
Red Bomb
One lobster tail, 1 Clusters of snow crab legs and half pound shrimp (no head) with one corn and two potatoes.
$55.89•83% (97)
Mr. Captain
#2 Most liked
1 Clusters of snow crab legs, half pound shrimp (no head), half pound sausage and two eggs with one corn and two potatoes.
$48.09•82% (182)
Plant Power
Broccoli, 3 pcs corn on the cob and 3 pcs potatoes
$13.30
The Black Pearl
2 Lobster tail, Snow crab (2 Cluster), 1lb green mussels, 1 lb Clams, 1 lb crawfish, 1 lb black mussels, 1 lb shrimp (no head), 1 lb sausage, 8 eggs, 8 corn, 16 potato
$200.19
Sides & Salad
Corn On The Cob (3)
Vegan.
$4.23•94% (55)
Potato (3)
Vegan.
$4.23•93% (45)
Steamed Rice
Soft and fluffy white rice, cooked to perfection.
$4.23•86% (46)
Boiled Eggs (2)
Two hard-boiled eggs, customizable with seasoning options: lemon pepper, Cajun, garlic butter, or Juicy Special. Choose your spice level from not spicy to extra hot.
$4.55•91% (70)
Side Broccoli
Vegan.
$4.88•88% (27)
Side Cauliflower
Vegan.
$6.17
French Fries
Fried potatoes.
$5.85•88% (9)
Cajun Fries
Cajun-seasoned French fries, crispy and golden.
$5.85•90% (32)
Sweet Potato Fries
Fried sweet potatoes.
$7.80
Cole Slaw
Vegan.
$3.85•87% (8)
Sausage
$10.40•91% (23)
House Salad
Vegan.
$7.79
Soda
Coke
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$4.55•83% (12)
Diet Coke
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
$4.55
Sprite
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
$4.55•88% (17)
Fanta
Bright and citrusy orange soda with natural flavors and no caffeine.
$4.55
Fruit Punch
A refreshing blend of juicy fruits, perfectly sweetened for a thirst-quenching treat.
$4.55
Dr Pepper
A blend of 23 flavors offering a unique, refreshing soda experience.
$4.55
Pink Lemonade
Refreshing, slightly tangy pink lemonade with a sweet, colorful twist.
$4.55•82% (17)
Sweet Tea
Refreshing sweet tea brewed to perfection.
$4.55
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash