Blue Chip Cookies at Coffee Cup Overflowing Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Blue Chip Cookies at Coffee Cup Overflowing
Sign In / Sign Up
Blue Chip Cookies (Coffee Cup Overflowing)
6544 Winford Ave, Fairfield Township OH 45011-0547, United StatesOpens 7:00 PM
Order for later
Featured Items
One Dozen Cookie Assortment
$24.00
Eight Cookie Assortment
$18.00
Three Dozen Cookie Assortment
$72.00
Sugar Iced (2 Cookies)
$5.00
Chocolate Chip (2 Cookies)
$4.50
Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
$5.00
Chocolate Chip M&M (2 Cookies)
$4.50
Confetti Cake, aka Birthday Cake Cookie
$4.50
Lemon Meringue (2 Cookies)
$4.50
Oatmeal Raisin (2 Cookies)
$4.50
Peanut Butter (2 Cookies)
$4.50
Sugar Old Fashioned (2 Cookies)
$4.50
White Chocolate Chip (2 Cookies)
$4.50
Deep Dish Cookie Cake-Small-5 Servings
$15.00
Cookie Monster
$5.00
Cookie Cake-1/2 Sheet, 28 to 30 Servings.
$57.00
Peanut Butter Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich
$5.00
Two Dozen Cookie Assortment
$48.00
Sugar Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich
$5.00
Big Deborah
$5.00
Buttercream Icing-4 oz of buttercream to ice your cookies or cakes!
$4.50
The Chipster (alias Cookie Sandwich)
$5.00
Chocolate Chip Macadamia (2 Cookies)
$4.50
Chocolate Chip Walnut (2 Cookies)
$4.50
Cinnamon Delight (Snickerdoodle) (2 Cookies)
$4.50
Full Menu
11:00 am - 3:40 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
One Dozen Cookie Assortment
Choose 6 flavors of Blue Chip cookies to create a delightful dozen.
$24.00
Eight Cookie Assortment
Choose four flavors for a delightful treat.
$18.00
Sugar Iced (2 Cookies)
Our sugar cookie with buttercream icing spread across the top! Delicious.
$5.00
Chocolate Chip (2 Cookies)
The big kahuna, the grand slam, the most wonderful chocolate chip cookie you will ever taste. Baked with our signature dough and secret ingredients, this cookie is the one to stand the test of time. Yummy to the last bite. Voted best cookie in over 10 cities.
$4.50
Three Dozen Cookie Assortment
Choose your favorite flavors for an impressive collection of cookies.
$72.00
Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
The Classic Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich! Two chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream in between. Just chill and enjoy!
$5.00
Chocolate Chip M&M (2 Cookies)
A colorful chocolate chip cookie combined with the famous Mars candy. Each cookie is baked with seasonal M&M's throughout the year.
$4.50
Confetti Cake, aka Birthday Cake Cookie
Our Confetti Cake is a version of our sugar cookie! First we mix beautiful sprinkles in the dough versus roll them in dough and add a special Birthday Cake extract that makes the cookie taste like a mini cake!
$4.50
White Chocolate Chip (2 Cookies)
Delicious Guittard White Chocolate in brown sugar cookie dough! We just substitute the semi-sweet for white chocolate. Creamy and scrumptious.
$4.50
Oatmeal Raisin (2 Cookies)
A favorite of many, our oatmeal raisin is made with raisins, oats and macaroon coconut.
$4.50
Cookie Assortments
Choose your favorite flavors for a delightful, indulgent treat!
Eight Cookie Assortment
Choose four flavors for a delightful treat.
$18.00
One Dozen Cookie Assortment
Choose 6 flavors of Blue Chip cookies to create a delightful dozen.
$24.00
Two Dozen Cookie Assortment
Choose up to 12 different flavors to create a delicious assortment of Blue Chip Cookies.
$48.00
Three Dozen Cookie Assortment
Choose your favorite flavors for an impressive collection of cookies.
$72.00
Cookie Creations by Auntie Em
Our resident Cookie Baker, Emily, will create unique Cookie Creations for your special occasion or when you want to indulge in a sweet treat.
Cookie Monster
Two chocolate chip cookies with your choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream icing in between, adorned with playful monster decorations.
$5.00
Peanut Butter Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich
Choose an Old Fashioned Vanilla ice cream, or deep, rich Zanzibar Chocolate, sandwiched between two Blue Chip Peanut Butter cookies for a delicious cold treat.
$5.00
Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
The Classic Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich! Two chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream in between. Just chill and enjoy!
$5.00
Sugar Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich
Enjoy a hand dipped scoop of Old Fashioned Vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two Sugar Cookies for a decadent treat! Enjoy with sprinkles or without.
$5.00
Big Deborah
Little Debbie is all grown up! Treat yourself to two Oatmeal Raisin cookies made into a delicious sandwich with a scoop of vanilla buttercream frosting, made from scratch in our kitchen.
$5.00
Chipster - Cookie Sandwich
Choose your cookie flavor, then choose between chocolate or vanilla buttercream frosting for the inside of this deliciously sweet sandwich.
$5.00
Cookie Cakes and Other Specialty Items
We have a nice variety of cookie cakes for any celebration: 7-inch, 13- inch, and 1/2 sheets. Try to order at least 1 day in advance, also give us at least 30 minutes to decorate the cake, if same day, without being rushed. We typically have all sizes on hand. Please select your icing colors, then type in the message you want on the cake and other info you want us to know in "Special Instructions." Make sure you let us know what message you want on the cookie cake. We can make cakes with advance notice in other flavors including Gluten Sensitive (no gluten flour added.)
Deep Dish Cookie Cake-Small-5 Servings
Personal Size Cookie Cake, Deep Dish-Serves 4-5 for a mini celebration. We decorate the border and can put small phrase on the cake or a simple symbol. Put your request in "Special Instructions."
Available in Chocolate Chip only.
$15.00
Cookie Cake-1/2 Sheet, 28 to 30 Servings.
The 1/2 sheet customized cookie cake-28 to 30 servings. Tell us what you want as your message on the cake. We can do simple symbols, also. 1/2 sheets are not always available, so order 3 days ahead of time.
$57.00
Buttercream Icing-4 oz of buttercream to ice your cookies or cakes!
Add more icing to your cakes or cookies!
Dip your pieces and cookies!
$4.50
"À La Carte"-Pick Your Flavors
Blue Chip Cookies has over 50+ flavors that we offer through the year. Every day we have available typically over 30 flavors to our customers. To ensure excellence in freshness, the cookies are baked to perfection, cool on our racks, and then we seal them as soon as possible "airtight" 2 cookies, the same flavor, into our proprietary bags. We label each one on the back with ingredients. We freeze the cookies immediately so we can offer this many flavors all the time. Please order one hour ahead if you want your cookies delivered at room temperature. Directions for serving are enclosed. If for future date, simply put them in your freezer and take out 1 hour prior to event.
The Chipster (alias Cookie Sandwich)
The Best Sandwich you will ever have, The Chipster. We put delicious vanilla buttercream icing in between two chocolate chip cookies!
$5.00
Chocolate Chip (2 Cookies)
The big kahuna, the grand slam, the most wonderful chocolate chip cookie you will ever taste. Baked with our signature dough and secret ingredients, this cookie is the one to stand the test of time. Yummy to the last bite. Voted best cookie in over 10 cities.
$4.50
Chocolate Chip Macadamia (2 Cookies)
Semi-sweet chocolates with macadamia nuts shipped from the big island! Aloha!
$4.50
Chocolate Chip M&M (2 Cookies)
A colorful chocolate chip cookie combined with the famous Mars candy. Each cookie is baked with seasonal M&M's throughout the year.
$4.50
Chocolate Chip Walnut (2 Cookies)
Our famous chocolate chip cookies baked with walnuts for a crispy, crunchy, nutty delight. What makes a good thing better? More good things.
$4.50
Cinnamon Delight (Snickerdoodle) (2 Cookies)
Our sugar cookie is infused with cinnamon and spice that has a profile that’s light and airy with great flavor. A favorite for many!
$4.50
Confetti Cake, aka Birthday Cake Cookie
Our Confetti Cake is a version of our sugar cookie! First we mix beautiful sprinkles in the dough versus roll them in dough and add a special Birthday Cake extract that makes the cookie taste like a mini cake!
$4.50
Cookies & Cream, aka OMG (2 Cookies)
Our sugar dough with Oreo cookie bits popping out all over!
$4.50
Lemon Delight (2 Cookies)
Our sugar cookie dough infused with lemon extract, light and airy!
$4.50
Lemon Meringue (2 Cookies)
Our Lemon Delight with Guittard White Chocolate Chips folded in, decadent and light.
$4.50
Oatmeal Raisin (2 Cookies)
A favorite of many, our oatmeal raisin is made with raisins, oats and macaroon coconut.
$4.50
Peanut Butter (2 Cookies)
Our signature dough is married with premium creamy-smooth peanut butter for that rich peanut-buttery goodness.
$4.50
Sugar Old Fashioned (2 Cookies)
Our classic Sugar Cookie, rolled in more sugar!
$4.50
Sugar with Season Sprinkles (2 Cookies)
Favorite amongst our younger fans and those who are young at heart, our sugar cookies are coated with seasonal sprinkles for that perfect treat. Holiday Sprinkles, Red, Green and White.
$4.50
Sugar Iced (2 Cookies)
Our sugar cookie with buttercream icing spread across the top! Delicious.
$5.00
Sugar Iced Spinkles(2 Cookies)
Sugar Iced with Seasonal Sprinkles.
$5.00
Sugar M&M (2 Cookies)
Our classic sugar cookies with seasonal M&Ms. Great cookie for the individual or kid that loves classic sugar with a festive milk chocolate candy to make it fun to eat and look at. This cookie brings the kid out in all of us. Delicious!
$4.50
White Chocolate Chip (2 Cookies)
Delicious Guittard White Chocolate in brown sugar cookie dough! We just substitute the semi-sweet for white chocolate. Creamy and scrumptious.
$4.50
White Chocolate Macadamia, alias Mac! (2 Cookies)
What Blue Chip Cookies is known for across the country. ”The first bakery to introduce the White Chocolate Chip Macadamia to the public!
$4.50
Buttercream Icing-4 ounces of buttercream to ice your own cookies or dip them into!
Enjoy spreading or dipping your cookie into our buttercream icing on the side.
$4.50
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash