Ritter's Frozen Custard - 4840 West 57th Street Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

Ritter's Frozen Custard

4840 W 57th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254, USA

Online ordering hours: 11:00 AM - 8:55 PM

Opens 11:00 AM

Order for later

Featured Items

#1 Most liked

Glaciers

$6.90

#2 Most liked

Strawberry Shortcake Sundae

$8.10

#3 Most liked

Create Your Own Sundae

$6.18

Turtle Sundae

$8.10

Brownie Sundae

$8.10

Banana Split

$9.48

Create Your Own Shake

$6.00

Mud Sundae

$8.10

Peanut Butter Mountain Sundae

$8.10

Pint

$8.40

Pineapple Upside Down Sundae

$8.10

Strawberry Delight

$8.10

Grizzly Cub Special

$8.10

Specialty and Fruit Blend Smoothie

$7.20

Hotdog

$4.20

Gelati Blend

$6.30

Gelati

$6.30

Dishes

$4.74

Worms N Dirt

$4.32

Italian Slush

$6.30

Kids Crunch

$4.32

Create Your Own Malt

$7.19

Cookie Dough Rock Slide

$4.32

Chocolate Marshmallow Cookie Dough Chunk Sundae

$8.10

Monkey In The Middle

$4.32

Full Menu

11:00 am - 8:55 pm

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Glaciers
#1 Most liked
Our version of a blizzard, vanilla or chocolate custard with one free mix in all blended together.
$6.90•Icon Loading91% (251)

Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
#2 Most liked
Vanilla frozen custard, shortcake, and strawberries.
$8.10•Icon Loading90% (113)

Create Your Own Sundae
#3 Most liked
Comes with one topping of your choice plus whipped cream and a cherry.
$6.18•Icon Loading92% (101)

Turtle Sundae
Vanilla frozen custard, hot fudge, hot caramel, and toasted pecans.
$8.10•Icon Loading79% (112)

Create Your Own Shake
Create a shake using our frozen custard and your choice of mix ins.
$6.00•Icon Loading85% (56)

Peanut Butter Mountain Sundae
Vanilla frozen custard, peanut butter topping & reese's cup.
$8.10•Icon Loading92% (56)

Brownie Sundae
Vanilla frozen custard, brownie, and hot fudge.
$8.10•Icon Loading90% (71)

Banana Split
Chocolate syrup, strawberries, pineapple & toasted pecans.
$9.48•Icon Loading74% (67)

Mud Sundae
Chocolate frozen custard, chocolate syrup, marshmallow creme & oreo cookies.
$8.10•Icon Loading100% (40)

Strawberry Delight
Vanilla frozen custard, strawberries, and sugar wafers.
$8.10•Icon Loading90% (44)

Hotdogs

Create your own Hotdog / Hotdog Combo

Hotdog Combo 2
ONE create your own hotdog with your choice of chips and a drink.
$7.20

Hotdog
Hotdog with your choice of toppings.
$4.20•Icon Loading89% (37)

Hotdog Combo 1
ONE create your own hotdog with your choice of chips.
$5.40•Icon Loading78% (14)

Hotdog Combo 3
TWO create your own hotdogs with your choice of chips and a drink.
$9.30•Icon Loading84% (32)

Dishes

Your flavor choice of custard in a dish

Dishes
Pick vanilla or chocolate, or any of our Italian Ice Flavors!
$4.74•Icon Loading100% (15)

Dog Dish
A kids scoop of vanilla with a dog treat on top.
$2.82•Icon Loading93% (30)

Create Your Own Sundae

Your flavor choice of custard in a dish with added toppings and whipped cream & cherry

Create Your Own Sundae
#3 Most liked
Comes with one topping of your choice plus whipped cream and a cherry.
$6.18•Icon Loading92% (101)

Shakes and Malts

Create Your Own Shake
Create a shake using our frozen custard and your choice of mix ins.
$6.00•Icon Loading85% (56)

Create Your Own Malt
Create a malt using our frozen custard and your choice of mix ins.
$7.19•Icon Loading90% (20)

Kids Favorites Sundaes

Worms N Dirt
Chocolate custard with oreos and gummy worms on top.
$4.32•Icon Loading92% (26)

Monkey In The Middle
Vanilla custard with strawberries and bananas on top.
$4.32•Icon Loading83% (18)

Cookie Dough Rock Slide
Vanilla custard with hot fudge, peanut butter and cookie dough on top.
$4.32•Icon Loading89% (37)

Kids Crunch
Vanilla custard with oreos, rainbow sprinkles, and m&m’s on top.
$4.32•Icon Loading78% (32)

Signature Sundaes

Strawberry Delight
Vanilla frozen custard, strawberries, and sugar wafers.
$8.10•Icon Loading90% (44)

Mud Sundae
Chocolate frozen custard, chocolate syrup, marshmallow creme & oreo cookies.
$8.10•Icon Loading100% (40)

Brownie Sundae
Vanilla frozen custard, brownie, and hot fudge.
$8.10•Icon Loading90% (71)

Grizzly Cub Special
Vanilla frozen custard, hot fudge, and Spanish peanuts.
$8.10•Icon Loading94% (34)

Turtle Sundae
Vanilla frozen custard, hot fudge, hot caramel, and toasted pecans.
$8.10•Icon Loading79% (112)

Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
#2 Most liked
Vanilla frozen custard, shortcake, and strawberries.
$8.10•Icon Loading90% (113)

Banana Split
Chocolate syrup, strawberries, pineapple & toasted pecans.
$9.48•Icon Loading74% (67)

Peanut Butter Mountain Sundae
Vanilla frozen custard, peanut butter topping & reese's cup.
$8.10•Icon Loading92% (56)

Pineapple Upside Down Sundae
Vanilla frozen custard, shortcake, pineapple, and hot caramel.
$8.10•Icon Loading96% (50)

Chocolate Marshmallow Cookie Dough Chunk Sundae
Chocolate frozen custard, cookie dough, and marshmallow crème.
$8.10

Cubby Paws

Cubby Paws
Ice cream sandwiches, vanilla, chocolate or strawberry.
$3.30•Icon Loading93% (15)

Quarts & Pints

Pint
1 pint of either vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and no-sugar-added vanilla.
$8.40•Icon Loading98% (53)

Glaciers

Disclaimer: please note that the syrups, including, hot fudge, hot caramel, marshmallow and chocolate syrup will make the glaciers a little more runny than solid toppings.

Glaciers
#1 Most liked
Our version of a blizzard, vanilla or chocolate custard with one free mix in all blended together.
$6.90•Icon Loading91% (251)

Smoothies

Coffee Lovers
$7.20•Icon Loading85% (7)

Specialty and Fruit Blend Smoothie
$7.20•Icon Loading85% (28)

Italian Ice

Our non-dairy option that you can get by the scoop, or as a slush!

Gelati
Our delicious vanilla custard layered with our Italian Ice!
$6.30•Icon Loading85% (20)

Italian Slush
Our version of a slushy! 
$6.30•Icon Loading88% (18)

Gelati Blend
Our vanilla custard blended up with the Italian Ice flavor of your choice!
$6.30•Icon Loading89% (19)

Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy